Charter Member of the Sub-Media

June 26, 2004

SSM Doesn't Affect My Marriage « Social Issues »

...but that was never more than a fallacious strawman argument, anyway.

Maggie Gallagher discusses some of the problems already emerging from the Massachusetts Supreme Court ruling.

Excerpt:

The advocates tell us the skies have not fallen in Massachusetts; nothing has changed, they assure us. Romney points out that small things have already begun to change, foretelling the bigger, sadder changes to come. First, the marriage licenses change so they no longer read husband and wife but "Party A" and "Party B." The Department of Health insists that birth certificates also change. The line for mother and father becomes "Parent A" and "Parent B."

[snip]

The transformation of mother and father into "Parent A" and "Parent B" is the model of the paradigm shift now underway in Massachusetts. The distinctive features of the union of male and female are going to have to be removed from our notions of marriage and family. The experience of same-sex couples will become the new norm for family life, because the "unisex" idea that gender has no public significance is the only model that can be construed as "inclusive" of both opposite-sex and same-sex unions. The result is not neutrality but the active promotion of a new unisex ideal, in which the distinctive features of opposite-sex relations will be submerged, marginalized, cast to one side, and redefined as discrimination in order to protect the new court-ordered public moral standard of the equality of same-sex and opposite-sex couples.

Some of you will be unmoved by this point. I'm sure that to some, this isn't a bug, it's a feature.

As Maggie points out:

The needs and desires of a tiny fraction of adults in alternative families are becoming the basis of a new moral norm. Anyone who departs from it risks thundering denunciation from self-righteous elites who are no longer satisfied with tolerance and civility — living with our deepest differences — but wish to impose their vision of morality on the majority.

We are in a cultural war right now. I wonder when it will erupt into open violence?

Posted by Nathan at 02:58 AM | Comments (0)
Comments
Post a comment









Remember personal info?