Brain Fertilizer: Was I Wrong About the Ghraib Prison Abuse?

May 17, 2004

Was I Wrong About the Ghraib Prison Abuse? Â« GWOT Â»

Phil Carter of Intel Dump has some good stuff regarding the Prison Abuses in Iraq in his post on 15 May.

If the sources are correct, and if his analysis is accurate, then I'm wrong about Gen. Karpinski, and Rumsfeld should step down. However, this is still in the early stages, and I'm not willing to concede anything; my assertions may still bear out. We'll see.

But like the Nick Berg story, this raises more questions than it answers.

Update:
This seems to answer the allegations well, in my opinion.

Posted by Nathan at 06:34 AM | Comments (6)

Comments

We saw this on the news last night in the form of a 30 second gloat.

I'm pretty sure I grabbed the Saran Wrap rather than the tinfoil to make my hat with, but the first thing that came to mind was that this was awfully frigging convenient.

Conspiracy theories aside, something doesn't feel right about this. I, too, am reserving judgement for the time being.

Posted by: Deb at May 17, 2004 08:30 AM

...I just didn't want to shy away from it because it didn't fit with my pre-disposed notions.

I did hesitate in blogging...but Phil has a good track record, good experience in the military and in intelligence, and understands law much better than I do. I figured at the very least I could acknowledge it and send people to look at his take on the issue.

Posted by: Nathan at May 17, 2004 08:40 AM

Hmmmmm.....

Posted by: Rae at May 17, 2004 08:47 AM

So far, I don't think I've disagreed with anything you've had to say on the subject--including this post.

I'm trying to wait a little to see what happens in the trials. I have strong feelings on the subject, but I think that a lot of it could be changing over the next few weeks.

Posted by: zombyboy at May 17, 2004 09:24 AM

I appreciate that you blogged it, Nathan, for precisely those reasons.

I'm not closed to the idea that I was very wrong about this (and possibly other things by extension), but I've definitely learned to wait patiently to let it all fall out before I opine.

Thing is, I can't seem to blog without commenting so I'm glad you did. :)

Posted by: Deb at May 17, 2004 10:16 AM

Auto-Submitter-Seo By Mr.php ==> ashq7a@att.net

ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ
ÌÇÊ
ÔÇÊ ÇáÚÑÇÞ
ÔÇÊ ÚÑÇÞí
ÔÇÊ ÚÑÇÞí
ÌÇÊ ÚÑÇÞí
ÌÇÊ ÇáÚÑÇÞ
ÌÇÊ ÚÑÇÞí
ÏÑÏÔå ÚÑÇÞíÉ
ÏÑÏÔå ÚÑÇÞíå
ÌÇÊ ÚÑÇÞí
ãæÓæÚå ÇáÚÑÇÞ
ãæÓæÚÉ ÔåÑÒÇÏ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáÚÑÇÞ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞíå
ÏÑÏÔå ÚÑÇÞíå
ßíãÒÑ
ÞíãÒÑ
gamezer
ÏæÑå ÇÍÊÑÇÝ ÇÎÊÑÇÞ ÇáãæÇÞÚ æÇáãäÊÏíÇÊ
ÏæÑå ÇÍÊÑÇÝ ÇÎÊÑÇÞ ÇáãæÇÞÚ æÇáãäÊÏíÇÊ
ÈÑÇãÌ åßÑ
ÈÑÇãÌ ÇÎÊÑÇÞ
ÇÈÑÇÌ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáÚÑÇÞ
ÏÑÏÔå ÚÑÇÞíå
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáÚÑÇÞ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞíÉ 100
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞíÉ ÑæãÇäÓíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞíå
ÚÑÇÞ
ÚÑÇÞíÉ
Ïáíá ÇáãæÇÞÚ ÇáÚÑÇÞíÉ
IraqI Directory
Iraqi CHat
ÚÑÇÞ ÇÈ
ÚÑÇÞ ÇÈ
ÚÑÇÞ ÇÈ
ãæÓæÚå ÔåÑÒÇÏ
ãÑßÒ ÊÍãíá ÕæÑ ÇáÚÑÇÞ
ÝÏíæ
ÇÛÇäí ÚÑÇÞíÉ
ÇáÚÇÈ
ÇáÚÇÈ ÝáÇÔ
ÏÑÏÔå ÚÑÇÞíÉ
]v]am uvhrdm
äÊÇÆÌ ÇáÓÇÏÓ 2011
ÏÑÏÔå ÚÑÇÞíÉ
ÚÑÇÞäÇ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞäÇ
ÔÇÊ ÚÑÇÞäÇ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞíÉ ÔÇÊ ÚÑÇÞí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ãÕÑíÉ ÔÇÊ ãÕÑí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÌÒÇÆÑíÉ ÔÇÊ ÌÒÇÆÑí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇÑÏäíÉ ÔÇÊ ÇÑÏäí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ßæíÊíÉ ÔÇÊ ßæíÊí
ÏÑÏÔÉ áíÈíÉ ÔÇÊ áíÈí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ãÛÑÈíÉ ÔÇÊ ãÛÑÈí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚãÇäíÉ ÔÇÊ ÚãÇäí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÞØÑíÉ ÔÇÊ ÞØÑí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÓæÏÇäíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÓæÑíÉ ÔÇÊ ÓæÑí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÊæäÓíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇãÇÑÇÊíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ íãäíÉ ÔÇÊ íãäí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÓÚæÏíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÈÍÑíäíÉ ÔÇÊ ÈÍÑíäí
ãæÓæÚÉ ÇáÎáíÌ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÓÚæÏíÉ
ÔÇÊ ÓÚæÏí
ÏÑÏÔÉ áíÈíÉ
ÔÇÊ áíÈí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇãÇÑÇÊíÉ
ÔÇÊ ÇãÇÑÇÊí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÈÍÑíäíÉ
ÔÇÊ ÈÍÑíäí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ãÕÑíÉ
ÔÇÊ ãÕÑí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚãÇäíÉ
ÔÇÊ ÚãÇäí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÓæÑíÉ
ÔÇÊ ÓæÑí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÞØÑíÉ
ÔÇÊ ÞØÑí
ÏÑÏÔå ßæíÊíÉ
ÏÑÏÔå ÝáÓØíäíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáäÌÝ
ÔÇÊ ÔåÑÒÇÏ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáÚãÇÑÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ Ïåæß
ÏÑÏÔå ÇÑÈíá
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáÍáÉ
ÏÑÏÔå ÇáÇäÈÇÑ
ÏÑÏÔå ÚÑÇÞäÇ
ÏÑÏÔå ÇáÓãÇæÉ
ÏÑÏÔå ÇáÈÕÑÉ
ÚÑÇÞ3
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáÍáÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÚÑÇÞ3
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÓáíãÇäíÉ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáÇäÈÇÑ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáÑãÇÏí
ÏÑÏÔÉ ßÑÈáÇÁ
ÏÑÏÔÉ ÇáäÇÕÑíÉ
ãæÞÚ ãÕØÝì ÇáÚÑÇÞí
ãÑßÒ ÊÍãíá
ÇÓÊÖÇÝÉ ÚÑÇÞíÉ
ÈæÇÈÉ ÇáÚÑÇÞ
ãäÊÏì