Charter Member of the Sub-Media

June 16, 2004

Just Asking... « GWOT »

So, can we question Susan Lindauer's patriotism? Or does the fact that John Kerry served in Viet Nam make that off-limits, too?

In the same vein, are Democrats seriously implying that once someone has been injured while serving their country, their patriotism can never be questioned? So if I, say, get injured on this deployment, I can freely sell secrets to Russia for the rest of my life and no one can touch me? No? Well, then, I think Senate voting records are fair game.

Posted by Nathan at 10:43 AM | Comments (6)
Comments

So,,, how do you feel our mulitple-amputee former elected official has been unpatriotic? Just curious.

And we've discussed my feelings on Lindauer already, so no sense in rehashing that.

Posted by: Jo at June 16, 2004 11:45 AM

That's just it: I don't think he is. I have not seen a single statement by any prominent or even semi-prominent Republican who said he is unpatriotic. They criticized his voting record, and response was "How dare you question his patriotism!?!?!"
Now, if you can provide an article or statement by a Republican that does call him unpatriotic, I'll apologize.
However, I've seen Kerry do the exact same thing:
Someone will say something like, "Sen. Kerry voted against the F-15, the B-1, and the M-1, weapons systems that were important in the Cold War mutual deterrence with the USSR and integral to our success in the Gulf War." and John Kerry will respond with "How dare they question my patriotism! I served in Viet Nam!" Yes, and protested against it and criticized his commanders and accused everyone of war crimes while still on active duty, then denied it later. That's not questioning his patriotism, that questioning his integrity. Big difference.

Posted by: Nathan at June 16, 2004 12:06 PM

And Jo, you're not helping matters by going to "questioning his patriotism" as the default interpretation of any criticism whatsoever.

Just sayin', is all.

Posted by: McGehee at June 16, 2004 02:57 PM

Not so fast, Kevin...Nathan used the word in his post first, hence my response. ;)

But you are so quick to jump, aren't ya? It's nice to see that despite the move to a new site, some things here stay the same. :)

Posted by: Jo at June 17, 2004 07:05 AM

Jo, he was talking about Lindauer, not Cleland.

Still so quick to squirm and redefine... ;-)

Posted by: McGehee at June 17, 2004 07:32 AM

Heck, I didn't even mention a triple amputee elected official anywhere in this post, and you still asked "How" did I consider him unpatriotic? You had already assumed I did. You were already accusing me of that smear.

That's exactly the point I'm making with this post.

Posted by: Nathan at June 17, 2004 09:57 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?